Articles by Jacqueline McDiarmid, Communication, connected, Couple's counselling, couples relationship counselling, couples therapy, expectations, online counselling, relationship therapy, Relationships, support

Online Counselling vs In-Person Counselling for Couples Therapy

When I first started as a Couples Therapist more than 25 years ago, everyone came to see me in person. There weren’t online video call options in those days. This meant that most of the couples I saw were people who lived locally to the practice or who were willing to travel to do couples counselling in the Sydney CBD area with me.

Now roughly 30% of couples see me for online couples therapy. Some moved from in-person to online couples counselling during COVID and never moved back. Some live in regional NSW or other Australian states, and some face logistical challenges (such as the need to keep an eye on young children, or challenges with transport).

I get people who ask if it’s better to do couples counselling in person, and whether online relationship counselling can work as well. The answer is, it depends on what issues the couple wants help with. It’s absolutely possible to do a lot of good work with couples online, but for deeper work, it’s better to bring people together in a physical space.

Online Couples Counselling vs. In-Person Couples Counselling: Comparison Table

 

In-person couples counselling

Online couples counselling

Best for

Deeper issues like affairs, betrayal and intimacy and couples in crisis

Busy couples, partners living apart or travelling, and couples in regional NSW or other Australian states

Setting

A private, neutral room away from home and work

Your own private space, with home comforts if they help with anxiety

Reading body language

Therapist is better placed to notice tension and small changes

Harder for the therapist to pick up small cues

Intensity

More intense, and often goes deeper

Can feel lower-intensity

Containing conflict and safety

Easier to contain a session and assess safety concerns

Harder to contain conflict and assess safety. Can feel safer as a first stage if one partner is frightened

Convenience

Travel required

No travel, can join from anywhere

Cons

Hard for couples who live apart or in different states

Home or work distractions, and a reliable internet connection is needed

Some couples start in person and then move online once they reach the maintenance stage.

What are the pros of in-person couples counselling?

  • It happens in a private, neutral space away from home, work and family. There are no ‘life distractions’ in the couples therapy room. The space supports focus – you’re designating time and space for your relationship. I offer couples counselling in the Sydney CBD from a beautiful room overlooking Hyde Park. It’s welcoming and comfortable, and I get a lot of positive feedback about how enjoyable it is to work in a space like this.
  • For issues like betrayal, affairs, intimacy and so on, it’s best to see a relationship therapist in person so the therapist can use their skills and experience to “read” you both. The therapist might observe changes in body language or tension. They are better placed to pick up on small facial movements or gestures. Being physically present means the therapist can be more attuned – but it has benefits for the couple too. Being in a room together often allows the work to go deeper. Physical presence supports emotional presence. (And we all know that it’s fairly easy to zone out or become distracted during online ‘meetings’).
  • Communication work benefits from in-person sessions. Communication is all about connection – and it works on several levels. Yes, it’s about what you say to each other, but it’s more than that. It’s about looking at each other, and hearing each other’s voices in real life (not through a tinny computer microphone). Couples are more likely to learn communication skills quickly and in a more profound way if they are in a room together.
  • Couples Therapists often use whiteboards to demonstrate ideas to the couple. This can be practical and helpful for a couple.  A whiteboard cannot be used online in the same way. OK, some readers will say ‘yes, but there’s screen sharing and online whiteboards and, and, and’. I promise you I have tried these, but it makes the whole thing feel like a business meeting. Relationship therapy is not a business meeting. It’s personal, emotional, and organic in a way that a commercial interaction is not.
  • If you and your partner are in crisis, and this is your last attempt at couples counselling, I really recommend seeing a therapist in person. Couples therapists who work in person can utilise frameworks that just do not translate online. You want to throw everything at it if your relationship is in crisis. And you want your therapist to be able to use all their skills, insights and nuanced observations to help you. There are ways that a therapist can get to the ‘heart of the matter’ in person that are substantially harder – and even impossible – online. Not sure whether things have reached that point? Here are the signs it’s time for couples counselling.

What are the cons of in-person couples counselling?

  • It can be difficult for busy couples to get to in-person sessions, especially if they are coming from different places, perhaps because of work commitments or the fact they are already living apart (if they have separated).
  • A couple might live in another state or country and cannot access the couples therapist they really want to work with unless there is an online option.

What are the pros of online couples counselling?

  • It’s so very convenient. Most people know how to access technology to make online sessions happen. If a couple are living separately, this can also be very helpful as they can dial in where they are.  It’s useful if one or both parties are travelling but still want to have sessions. And we all get sick at some point – therapists too! No germs are shared online. Here are 10 more benefits of telehealth counselling.
  • If a couple commits to staying focused and really being present online, it’s possible to do most of the work that’s possible in real-life sessions. Yes, there are some limitations – but people can still learn a great deal and benefit from online couples therapy.
  • A lot of couples prefer the couples counselling to have a lower intensity to it. Online couples counselling can feel less intense than in-person work for some. That can be handy. In some instances, such as situations where there is physical abuse in a relationship, or one person is frightened or traumatised by their partner, online couples therapy can feel safer. It can be a useful first stage that may eventually move to in-person therapy if the therapist and the couple agree.
  • A lot of couples benefit from being in their own private space when in couples counselling sessions. Again, this can allow people to take breaks, or have pets or home comforts with them to help with anxiety and support the work.

What are the cons of online couples counselling?

  • It is a lot more difficult for a couples therapist to contain a session – especially if there is conflict.
  • It can be difficult for a couples therapist to assess if there are safety concerns between the couple.
  • As stated above, the intensity and effectiveness of couples counselling online may not be as good as in-person therapy, simply because there is not the same intimacy.
  • The couple might be dialling in from a home or workplace and be distracted or interrupted by others.
  • Online sessions mean that the internet connection needs to be relied upon, and we all know this sometimes doesn’t work out. A slow or bad connection can mean the couples counselling is clunky and frustrating for everyone.

Online Couples Therapy or In-Person: Which is right for you?

What do I think given I do both online and in-person sessions?  Ideally if you can do in-person sessions, you should.  You and your partner will just get a lot more out of in-person sessions.

But it is also possible to do a hybrid of both. I sometimes start off people in-person and then move them to online work when we are at the maintenance stage of the work. This seems to work well for couples.

And if there is a couples therapist you really want to work with and they only have online availability, I think you should take that option. In my view and experience, it’s a better option than choosing someone with less experience or fewer qualifications simply because they offer in-person therapy. Here’s more on choosing the right couples counsellor. A lot of my couples say they are very happy with what they get out of online relationship counselling with me. Do what is best for you and your relationship.

Written by Jacqueline McDiarmid – not a robot.

About Jacqueline Jacqueline has been in private practice for more than two decades, helping individuals, couples and families.  She has extensive experience in couple and family therapy and is considered a specialist in these areas. In her clinical practice, she has helped people deal with complex trauma, affairs, complex mental health issues, eating disorders, adolescent behavioural problems (including self-harm and suicidal ideation), behavioural issues in young children which are impacting parents and families, relationship issues and post-separation work. Jacqueline works with many different dynamics: couples, parents, families with young children, same-sex couples, foster/adopted families, families with teenagers and also adult families.  She is particularly interested in helping parents of children with behavioural issues, or with diagnosed conditions such as anxiety, ADHD, ASD and so on. Although Jacqueline’s work is supportive and friendly, she will challenge her couples and families to make the necessary behavioural changes, to repair relationships and to move towards healthier communication styles in the future. Jacqueline’s style is direct and fast paced and she is known for quickly getting to the heart of the matter.  Clients report that they feel safe and understood with Jacqueline.
 
Qualifications and Professional Membership Jacqueline has a Masters in Couple and Family Therapy (UNSW). She has a Bachelor degree in Counselling and Human Change, and a Diploma in Psychotherapy and Counselling. Jacqueline is a Clinical Supervisor for Counsellors and Therapists. She lectures in couple and family therapy at Masters and Post Graduate level, and is currently Head Lecturer for the Couple and Family Therapy course (Masters) at the Jansen Newman Institute.  She has been a Lecturer at the University of Western Sydney and Sydney University, and continues to guest lecture at other tertiary institutions. Jacqueline is also the Director of the Couple and Family Training Centre where she runs regular professional development workshops and seminars for Therapists, Counsellors, Psychologists, Social Workers and Health Industry Workers who are looking to gain skills in this specialist area. She is a Clinical Member of the Family Therapy Association of Australia and a Clinical Member of PACFA.
 
“Thank you for seeing me today. Your help with all our family issues and all your advice has been invaluable. I don’t know how other families do it, without a Jacqueline in their lives.” – Anna (43) step-mum and mum to four children.
 

If you’re struggling in your relationship and need professional support, don’t wait. Complete the contact form and include a brief note describing your unique situation so Jacqueline McDiarmid or one of our experienced Couples Counsellors can best support you. You can also contact The Sydney Couple and Family Specialists directly on 02 8968 9397 to take the first step toward meaningful change today.

Contact Us Today

    Please only click send ONCE and wait a few seconds!

    Sign up today to get tools and strategies to build your relationship


    location

    Call us Today Book FREE Consultation